India Crypto Tax Stays Stiff: Budget 2024 Dashes Industry Hopes as 1% TDS Remains

Frustration echoes within India’s crypto community as Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman presented the annual budget, and the much-anticipated relief for crypto taxes remained absent. The controversial tax deducted at source (TDS) policy on crypto transactions, a thorn in the side of the industry, is here to stay – at least for now.

Crypto Tax Status Quo: What Happened in the Budget?

Despite fervent appeals from the domestic crypto industry and compelling research advocating for tax relief, the budget unveiled on Thursday maintained silence on any revisions to the existing crypto tax framework. This includes the much-debated 30% tax on crypto profits and the 1% TDS on all crypto transactions. For those in the crypto space, this news is undoubtedly a setback. Many hoped that the government would reconsider its stance, especially given the ongoing challenges the industry faces.

Why is the 1% TDS a Major Concern for Indian Crypto?

The 1% TDS, introduced two years ago, has been a persistent headache for Indian crypto exchanges and traders alike. It’s not just about the percentage itself; it’s about the cascading effects it has had on the market. Let’s break down why this policy is so problematic:

• Liquidity Drain: The TDS applies to every transaction, regardless of profitability. This means even if you’re trading at a loss, 1% of your transaction value is locked up as TDS. This significantly reduces trading capital and overall market liquidity.
• Exchange Exodus: The high tax regime has pushed many Indian crypto users towards offshore exchanges that do not comply with Indian tax laws. This capital flight weakens domestic exchanges and reduces potential tax revenue for the government in the long run.
• Operational Challenges for Exchanges: Indian crypto exchanges are struggling to stay afloat. The TDS has increased their compliance burden and reduced trading volumes, impacting their revenue streams and forcing many to extend their financial runways just to survive.
• Hinders Growth of Web3: As Dilip Chenoy, chairman of the Bharat Web3 Association, points out, high taxes are driving both creators and consumers out of India. This directly hampers the growth of the Web3 ecosystem in the country.

Industry Voices: Disappointment and Hope for the Future

The crypto industry’s reaction to the budget has been a mix of disappointment and cautious optimism. Dilip Chenoy of the Bharat Web3 Association, a key policy advocate for India’s Web3 sector, shared his perspective:

“We didn’t anticipate major policy shifts in an interim budget. However, we are keenly focused on post-election changes. The current high TDS and income tax rates are undoubtedly pushing talent and transactions offshore, which is detrimental to the Indian Web3 landscape.”

His statement reflects the industry’s understanding that interim budgets usually avoid major policy changes, especially in an election year. The hope now rests on the upcoming general elections and the subsequent full budget, where the industry hopes for a more favorable crypto tax policy.

The Numbers Don’t Lie: Impact of High Crypto Taxes

The Esya Centre, a think tank, conducted a study that quantifies the adverse effects of the government’s crypto tax policy. Their findings are quite revealing:

• $420 Million Revenue Loss: Since the implementation of the stringent tax regime in July 2022, the government has potentially lost out on $420 million in revenue. This is due to reduced trading activity on domestic exchanges and capital migration to offshore platforms.
• 5 Million Traders Moved Offshore: An estimated five million crypto traders have shifted their activities to offshore exchanges to avoid the high taxes. This significant exodus underscores the policy’s unintended consequence of driving economic activity away from India.

These figures paint a clear picture: the current tax policy, while intended to generate revenue and regulate the crypto sector, might be doing more harm than good by stifling growth and pushing economic activity offshore.

Government’s Stance: A Balancing Act?

While the government has not reduced the crypto tax rates, it has recently taken steps to address the issue of offshore crypto exchanges. By acting against non-compliant platforms, the government aims to bring crypto activity back to Indian exchanges. This action could be interpreted as a move to consolidate crypto trading within the regulated domestic space, even with the existing tax structure.

Is this a balancing act? Perhaps the government is trying to enforce regulation and compliance first, before considering tax revisions. Or maybe, they believe the current tax rates are justified despite industry concerns. Whatever the rationale, the crypto industry remains in a state of watchful anticipation.

Looking Ahead: What’s Next for Crypto Tax in India?

The lack of changes in this budget is not the end of the road. Here’s what the crypto community and stakeholders should consider moving forward:

• Continued Advocacy: The Bharat Web3 Association and other industry bodies must continue their dialogue with the government, presenting data and research to highlight the negative impacts of the current tax regime and advocating for a more balanced approach.
• Focus on the Full Budget: All eyes are now on the full budget after the general elections. This will be the next critical opportunity for the crypto industry to push for tax reforms.
• Compliance and Innovation: Domestic exchanges should focus on maintaining compliance and fostering innovation within the existing regulatory framework. Building robust and user-friendly platforms will be crucial to attract and retain users.
• Investor Education: Educating investors about tax implications and compliance is essential. This can help users navigate the current system and make informed decisions.

Conclusion: A Waiting Game for Crypto Relief

For the Indian crypto industry, the budget announcement is a mixed bag. The continuation of the 1% TDS is undoubtedly a disappointment. However, the industry’s resilience and the anticipation of post-election policy changes offer a glimmer of hope. The message is clear: the fight for a more favorable crypto tax regime is far from over. The coming months will be crucial as the industry continues to engage with the government and advocate for policies that foster growth and innovation in the Indian crypto and Web3 space. Until then, it’s a waiting game, with fingers crossed for positive changes on the horizon.

#Binance #WRITE2EARN