India’s Crypto Crossroads: Ban or Regulation as RBI and Experts Clash?

The world of cryptocurrency in India is currently navigating a turbulent phase. On one side, you have voices advocating for a complete ban, while on the other, there’s a push for a more regulated approach. It’s a tug-of-war that has the Indian crypto community and investors on edge. Let’s dive into the heart of this debate and understand what’s shaping the future of crypto in India.

The Push for a Crypto Ban: RBI and SJM’s Stance

Leading the charge for a complete cryptocurrency ban are some influential voices, most notably the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM).

• RBI’s Firm Stance: During a recent meeting, the RBI’s central board of directors reportedly made it clear – they believe a partial ban on cryptocurrency won’t cut it. Their stance is for an outright prohibition, signaling serious concerns about the potential impact of cryptocurrencies on the Indian economy.
• SJM’s Nationalist Call: Adding weight to the ban calls is the Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM), an affiliate of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. They’ve also passed resolutions urging the government to impose a complete ban on cryptocurrencies. This reflects a broader sentiment in some circles about the perceived risks and disruptions associated with digital currencies.

Legal Experts Advocate for Balanced Regulation

While the calls for a ban are strong, a contrasting viewpoint is emerging from legal experts. They argue that turning back the clock on cryptocurrency might not be the most effective solution. Instead, they emphasize the need for robust and well-thought-out regulations. Why this approach?

Why Regulation Might Be the Way Forward?

• Investor Protection: A key argument for regulation is safeguarding investors. The crypto market, known for its volatility, can be risky. Regulations can introduce measures to protect investors from scams, fraud, and extreme market fluctuations.
• Preventing Uncontrolled Growth: Without any framework, the cryptocurrency market could potentially grow unchecked. Experts warn this could pose risks to India’s foreign exchange reserves and potentially destabilize the economy. Regulation aims to bring this growth under control.
• Cryptocurrencies as Investment Instruments: The government seems to be leaning towards recognizing cryptocurrencies as investment assets. This perspective naturally leads to the need for regulation, similar to other asset classes, to manage them within the existing financial system.

Taxation and Clarity: Key Areas for Regulation

Legal experts are pointing out specific areas where clear regulations are urgently needed:

• Income Tax: Currently, the tax status of cryptocurrencies isn’t entirely clear. Experts suggest they are likely to be treated as assets under income tax rules, attracting capital gains tax. Clear guidelines are needed for investors to understand their tax obligations.
• GST and TDS: The application of Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) to cryptocurrency transactions is another grey area. Regulations need to clarify how these taxes will apply to crypto dealings.

India’s Unique Position: Not a Free Market Like Developed Nations

A crucial point highlighted by experts is that India’s approach to cryptocurrency regulation needs to be distinct from that of developed countries. Why? Because of India’s foreign exchange regulations.

Foreign Exchange Restrictions: A Key Differentiator

Executive partner L. Badri Narayanan of Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan Attorneys points out a fundamental difference:

“The government is viewing cryptocurrencies as investment instruments and plans to regulate them. Under income tax rules, cryptocurrencies are likely to be assets and attract capital gains. GST and TDS are other areas where the position of law is not clear.”

He further emphasizes the challenges in controlling cross-border crypto transactions in India:

“You cannot take money out of India without permission. We are a foreign exchange-regulated market and that means we cannot take certain decisions like developed countries that have a free market.”

This means that unlike countries with fewer restrictions on capital outflow, India needs to carefully consider how to manage the flow of cryptocurrency funds in and out of the country. The Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) governs import/export and cross-border movement of goods and services, and cryptocurrency regulations will likely need to align with this framework.

Global Policy is Essential: IMF’s Chief Economist Weighs In

Adding a global perspective to the debate, International Monetary Fund (IMF) chief economist Gita Gopinath recently highlighted the practical difficulties of banning cryptocurrencies. She stressed the importance of a global, coordinated policy for cryptocurrencies. This is because:

• Decentralized Nature: Cryptocurrencies, by design, are decentralized. This makes it inherently challenging for any single nation to effectively ban or control them completely within its borders.
• Cross-border Transactions: Crypto transactions can easily cross national borders, making unilateral bans less effective and potentially pushing crypto activity underground or to less regulated jurisdictions.

What’s Next? The Indian Crypto Bill and the Winter Session

The Indian cryptocurrency bill is currently under review by the government and is expected to be tabled during the winter session of parliament. The administration has stated that it is revising the bill, suggesting that the final shape of crypto regulation in India is still being actively debated and formulated.

The coming months will be crucial in determining the direction India takes – will it be a complete ban, a carefully crafted regulatory framework, or something in between? The world is watching, and the Indian crypto community waits with bated breath.

Related Posts – Bank DBS’s Crypto Business Grows Massively Due To Growing Demand From Investors