SHRINCS Gains Ground as Bitcoin Post-Quantum Signature Pick
In this article
Blockstream Research Director Jonas Nick and researcher Mikhail Kudinov published a security analysis on Thursday, November 19, 2026, for SHRINCS, a hash-based signature scheme now positioned as an emerging frontrunner for post-quantum security in Bitcoin, according to Decrypt. Kudinov, a post-quantum cryptography researcher at Blockstream, said the draft Bitcoin Improvement Proposal needs review from engineers, cryptographers and protocol developers.
Two spending paths, two very different risks
SHRINCS splits signing into two routes. The stateful option is small and keeps transactions manageable, but each key can safely sign only once. If a wallet accidentally reuses a one-time state, an attacker can forge a signature for that address and take the funds — a failure Nick described as catastrophic and one that should be impossible for users to trigger on their own.
The stateless option is bigger and more expensive but carries fewer implementation risks. Nick said the rule for real-world use should be simple: if a state counter could be compromised in any way, the specification and wallet software should fall back to the stateless path without asking the user.
That safety net has a cost. Nick noted that widespread stateless use could bloat the blockchain and push fees higher, since fewer transactions would fit into each block. “We don’t know what the fee market will look like once we have these very big signatures,” he said, adding that it also affects how many people can use Bitcoin.
Both paths are under active optimization, supported in part by AI-assisted research, according to Nick. The proposal’s viability now hinges on feedback from the network’s stakeholders and further refinement of the specification.
Why it matters
Bitcoin’s signature scheme is the gatekeeper for every spend, so any migration is a years-long coordination problem touching wallets, exchanges, custody providers and node software. SHRINCS offers a conservative route because it avoids introducing new cryptographic assumptions beyond SHA-256, but the efficiency-versus-safety trade-off sits squarely with wallet developers who must enforce key-state tracking. Security incidents such as the FBI’s November 2026 warning that North Korean hackers stole $400 million through fake meetings are a reminder that implementation errors, not just cryptography, drive the largest losses in this sector.
What to watch
The SHRINCS working group is still refining the proposal’s specification, and Nick and Kudinov have asked engineers and cryptographers to review both the draft BIP and the security analysis. How wallet teams respond to the mandatory stateless-fallback requirement will be the first real test of whether the scheme can move from research to production.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Bitcoin need a post-quantum signature scheme at all?
SHRINCS is being developed as a contingency for the possibility that quantum computing could eventually threaten Bitcoin’s current ECDSA and Schnorr signatures. The proposal anchors its security in SHA-256, a hash function Bitcoin already relies on, to keep trust assumptions narrow.
What is the difference between the stateful and stateless SHRINCS signatures?
The stateful path is compact and efficient but each one-time key can safely sign only one transaction; reuse would let an attacker forge a signature and steal funds. The stateless path is larger and costlier but carries fewer implementation risks.
How much bigger are SHRINCS signatures than today’s Bitcoin signatures?
Per the analysis, SHRINCS stateful signatures range from 548 to 4,619 bytes and stateless ones are 5,777 bytes, compared with roughly 71 bytes for ECDSA and 64 bytes for Taproot Schnorr.
Has SHRINCS been approved for Bitcoin?
No. As of November 19, 2026, it remains a draft Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, and its authors are asking engineers, cryptographers and protocol developers for review and feedback.
Source: Decrypt


